Monday, May 11, 2009

Punishment for Students

I was talking with a parent today who explained to me that his daughter received a citation from school and he couldn't remember where he put the note.  Each day that it does not return to school signed by a parent, his daughter gets detention.  So in other words, she gets punished for her father's mistake.  You could argue that the student is responsible for returning important papers to school, but she is only in first grade for crying out loud.  Why can't the teacher just call the parents themselves? 

4 comments:

  1. I think both the teacher and the parents should be responsible for this matter. A first grade student is too young to remember anything that may happen at school. Parents should ask their children what happens during the day, and then the child will remember to show them the citation. Teacher also needs to follow up, if she so not turn it in, give the parent a call.

    PH Ton

    ReplyDelete
  2. Responsibility is something that is in short supply these days. I understand the need to hold the parent and student accountable for their actions, but the continuance of the detention assignment is a bit much. It would appear that this particular instructor may be "power-tripping" or they are incredibly strict in their application of classroom rules and protocol.

    -Jason O. (GED 500 Sp 09)

    ReplyDelete
  3. It will be time to make at least one phone call to review the need of the parent to check the homework folder every evening and return the required paperwork to the teacher. This issue should have been presented at the beginning of school. The responsibility belongs to the parents and a review of classroom policy is in order. This will shift ownership of the problem back to the parent.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I think this teacher is a bit power hungry. Detention for a first grader is ridiculous. I understand sending a note home with the student, however, the parent not signing it should not result in detention for the student. If this is as serious of an issue for the teacher as it seems to be, then he needs to contact the parent. Now that is has happened, the father needs to have a serious conversation with the teacher and if this does not result in satisfactory results, talk to the principal.

    ReplyDelete